Google Stadia Review: Gaming’s Streaming Future Isn’t Here Yet
See the original posting on Slashdot
Scott Stein, reviews Google Stadia cloud gaming service for CNET: Stadia’s launch day was earlier this week… sort of. Really, consider this the start of Stadia’s early-access beta period. Because Google’s big promises haven’t arrived, and at the price of the Stadia’s Founder’s Edition, I can’t recommend anyone jump onboard at the moment. Google’s experimental game streaming service, Stadia, launches without many of its promised features, and just a handful of games. It works, but there’s not much incentive to buy in. We’ve heard about the promises of streaming games over the internet for a decade. Stadia really does work as a way to stream games. I’ve only played a couple of the 12 games Google promised by Tuesday’s launch, though. That short list pales compared to what Microsoft already has on tap for its in-beta game-streaming service, xCloud. It’s no match for what Nvidia’s game streaming GeForce Now already has or what PlayStation Now offers. Prices of Stadia games at launch in the US are below. They’re basically full retail game prices. This could get crazy expensive fast.
[…] Stadia has so few games right now, and I’m trying them with no one else online. It isn’t clear how things will work now that the service is going live, and what other features will kick in before year’s end. I’m curious, but I might lose interest. Others might, too. I have plenty of other great games to play right now: on Apple Arcade, VR and consoles such as the Switch. Stadia isn’t delivering new games yet, it’s just trying to deliver a new way to play through streaming. One that you can already get from other providers. Until Google finds a way to loop in YouTube and develop truly unique competitive large-scale games, Stadia isn’t worth your time yet. Yes, the future is possibly wild, and you can see hints of the streaming-only cloud-based playground Stadia wants to become. But we’ll see what it shapes into over the next handful of months and check back in. Raymond Wong, writing for Input Mag looks at the amount of data playing a game on Stadia consumes and how the current state of things require a very fast internet connection to work: Like streaming video, streaming games is entirely dependent on your internet speed. Faster internet delivers smooth, lag-free visuals, and slower internet means seeing some glitches and dropped framerates. Google recommends a minimum of connection of 10Mbps for 1080p Full HD streaming at 30 fps with stereo sound and 35Mbps for 4K resolution streaming (in HDR if display is supported) at 60 fps with 5.1 surround sound. Reality didn’t reflect Google’s advertising, though. Despite having a Wi-Fi connection with 16-20Mbps downloads in a hotel room in LA, streaming Shadow of the Tomb Raider and Destiny 2 to my 13-inch MacBook Pro wasn’t 100% stable. The visuals would glitch out for a second or two about every 10 minutes of playtime. […] A fast internet connection isn’t the only thing you need for Stadia to work right. You need a lot of bandwidth, too. One hour of playing Red Dead Redemption 2 at 1080p resolution on my 46-inch HDTV via a Chromecast Ultra ate up 5.3GB of data. This seemed insane until I saw an hour of Destiny 2 on a Pixel 3a XL with 6-inch, 1080p-resolution display gobbled up 9.3GB of data!
Read more of this story at Slashdot.